Scholes: Amorim ‘Doesn’t Like’ Ugarte — What That Means for Mainoo and United

Paul Scholes has chimed in with his characteristic no-nonsense verdict on Manchester United’s midfield merry-go-round, and it’s not exactly comforting reading for supporters of Kobbie Mainoo or Manuel Ugarte.

Scholes points the finger at Ugarte

Speaking on The Overlap YouTube channel, Scholes suggested that Amorim is still feeling his way through several options in the centre and hasn’t settled on a pair that convinces him. The former United midfield maestro was clear in his assessment: Amorim seems to be favouring the Casemiro-Bruno Fernandes axis and, according to Scholes, doesn’t really fancy Manuel Ugarte.

What that means for Kobbie Mainoo

Mainoo, the 20-year-old academy graduate, has found opportunities thin on the ground — only given a single Premier League substitute appearance so far this season. He even asked for a loan move to get regular minutes but was told to fight for a spot alongside the likes of Bruno Fernandes instead. Scholes’ comments will only add fuel to the debate over whether that was the right call from United’s hierarchy.

Previous relationship doesn’t guarantee selection

There was an assumption Amorim’s arrival would slot Ugarte straight back into favour after their time together at Sporting. In reality, Amorim’s past words about his midfield options hinted he valued others — he’s previously put Morten Hjulmand ahead of Ugarte when discussing who he thought was the most complete option. That snub, Scholes argues, explains Ugarte’s omission so far this Premier League campaign.

Reality check: minutes, form and a cup setback

Ugarte hasn’t started any of United’s three league matches to date and did struggle when given a full game in the Carabao Cup reverse at Grimsby. To add context, the two did work together a lot at Sporting — Ugarte logged plenty of appearances under Amorim — but past familiarity doesn’t always equal present preference.

Pundit verdict and what United should do next

From where I’m standing, this is a selection headache that’s down to philosophy as much as personnel. If Amorim truly leans towards a holding-mid plus Bruno system, United must either back that long-term or be brave enough to adapt — playing a different balance of energy, press and ball progression. Mainoo needs minutes to develop; leaving him on the bench is a gamble. Ugarte, meanwhile, must respond quickly or risk becoming a peripheral figure despite previous investment.

Fans can argue all they like — but Scholes’ blunt take is a reminder that managers make hard choices and reputations from previous clubs don’t guarantee a spot at Old Trafford. If you want to keep tabs on the broader betting angles around team news and match odds, check out betting sites for up-to-the-minute markets and insights.